Using a Comma Before “Which”: The Grammarian’s DilemmaUsing a Comma Before “Which”

Using a comma before "which"

Key Takeaways:

Using a comma before “which” can drastically change the meaning of your sentence.

  • Comma usage in relation to “which” hinges on understanding restrictive and nonrestrictive clauses.
  • Misusing commas with “which” can lead to real-world errors and misunderstandings.
  • Style guides generally agree on these rules, but some minor differences exist.
  • Mastering this aspect of grammar is crucial for clear and effective writing.

Welcome, dear friend, to the labyrinth of English grammar, where the comma—that tiny little punctuation mark—can turn meanings topsy-turvy. Misplacing a comma can ignite confusion in your sentences. But fear not! I’m here to guide you through the fiery pits of punctuation, precisely when to use a comma before “which.”

Understanding Relative Clauses: Grammar’s Secret Sauce

Meet the Relatives

Relative clauses are used to infuse your sentences with depth. They’re akin to caramelized onions in a burger—not essential, but undeniably enhancing the flavor. For example, “A koala is a bear that likes to eat eucalyptus.” In this example, the bear’s cuisine preference is a relative clause—not essential but helpful context. Relative clauses are preceded by a relative pronoun, such as the word “that,” “whose,” or “which.” In that sense, relative pronouns are versatile tools used that introduce relative clauses to elevate your writing.

Restrictive vs. Nonrestrictive: A Tale of Two Clauses

There are two types of relative clauses: restrictive and nonrestrictive. A restrictive clause is essential to the meaning of your sentence (like cheese in a cheeseburger). For example, “The person who wrote this article is a renowned author.” A nonrestrictive clause is extra information that is not essential to the meaning (like the pickles—excellent, but the burger’s still a burger without them). For example, “The author of this article, Jane Smith, is a renowned author.”

When to Use a Comma Before “Which”: The Cheeseburger Rule

Now that we’ve had a delicious bite of the flavorful ingredients in our grammatical cheeseburger, let’s take a moment to delve deeper into the art of punctuation using commas. Understanding when to use a comma before “which” is a skill that revolves around comprehending the nuances between restrictive and nonrestrictive clauses. So, grab your metaphorical spatula, and let’s continue our exploration of the grammar rules.

A Nonrestrictive Nibble

Nonrestrictive clauses, where “which” often hangs out, are always introduced by a comma. For example, “My bike, which is red, has a flat tire.” The fact the bike is red isn’t essential—it’s just a bonus detail.

When Not to Use a Comma Before “Which”: Hold the Pickles!

Before we delve into the cases where you should not use a comma before “which”, let’s take a quick breather to soak in what we’ve learned so far. We’ve covered the fundamentals of restrictive and nonrestrictive clauses and understood why a comma accompanies “which” in the latter. But, just like every rule has an exception, sometimes “which” doesn’t need to be accompanied by a comma. Let’s unravel the cases where a comma before “which” is a no-go.

The Restrictive Rule

When “which” introduces a restrictive clause, you drop the comma. For instance, “I need a book which can help me learn Spanish.” Here, specifying the type of book is essential—it’s not just any book you need, but a Spanish learning one.

Common Misconceptions and Mistakes: The Punctuation Pitfalls

Just like confusing salt with sugar can ruin your coffee, mixing up your commas can mess up your sentence. For example, “I enjoyed the book which was full of suspense” means that of all the books, you enjoyed the suspenseful one. But if you write, “I enjoyed the book, which was full of suspense,” means you enjoyed it, and oh, by the way, it was suspenseful.

Contrasting “Which” with “That”: The Grammarian’s Showdown

In the American English showdown, “that” typically takes the crown as the restrictive relative pronoun, while “which” often introduces nonrestrictive clauses. In American English, people often say, “I’m looking for a book that can help me learn Spanish.”

The Importance of Audibility and Rhythm: The Grammar Symphony

Grammar isn’t just visual; it’s also auditory. Reading your sentences aloud can help you feel the rhythm and detect where natural pauses (and, thus, commas) should be. It’s like tapping your foot to a catchy tune—if it feels offbeat, something might be amiss.

Style Guides and Their Recommendations: The Rulebooks of Writing

Style guides like APA, Chicago, and MLA mostly agree on these comma rules. However, they differ slightly on “which” vs. “that” usage, which can be a point of contention among writers. It’s like preferring cheddar over Swiss on your burger—both options are acceptable, but people often have their preferences based on factors like taste, texture, and overall flavor profile. 

Similarly, writers may have their own reasons for favoring one usage over the other, such as clarity, emphasis, or personal style. Despite these nuanced differences, it’s important to remember adherence to these style guides can help ensure consistency and professionalism in your writing.

The Broader Implications for Clear Writing: The Big Picture

Why does this seemingly insignificant comma hold importance? It’s because precision in writing is the catalyst for clarity in communication. And when communication is clear, writing becomes truly effective. Mastering when to use a comma before “which” is not just about grammar—it’s about ensuring your reader understands exactly what you mean.

Wrapping Up the Comma Conundrum

So there you have it, my friend—the ins and outs of when to use a comma before “which.” Remember, grammar isn’t a scary monster under the bed; it’s just a tool to help us communicate clearly. And now that you’ve got this tool in your writer’s toolkit, you’re well on your way to crafting more precise and compelling prose.

Rick Leach

Article by

Rick Leach, the Vice President of Content Operations at Crowd Content, is a seasoned professional in orchestrating large-scale content initiatives. At the helm of a dynamic team of content managers, QA specialists, and production assistants, he oversees the team’s production of high-quality content for businesses around the globe. Rick's expertise extends beyond operations management to providing strategic insights on scaling and producing outstanding content, making him a respected voice in the content creation industry.

Rick's journey in the content industry is preceded by more than five years as an Advertising Sales Manager at The Tampa Tribune, where he refined his skills in media sales and advertising. And his entrepreneurial spirit is evident in his successful 17-year venture as the proprietor of an e-commerce business.

On a personal front, Rick's life is as fulfilling as his professional endeavors. A proud U.S. Navy veteran, he enjoys a blissful family life, married with four children and a grandchild. Originally from New England but now residing on the Gulf Coast of Florida, Rick is an avid fan of the Boston Red Sox and the New England Patriots.

Powered by Crowd Content image

Content Creation for Your Blog

Get More Info
Writers Hub

Using a Comma Before “And”: Navigating the Comma …

Continue reading

Writers Hub

Elevate Your Writing Skills: Top 10 Content Blunders to Avoi …

Continue reading